A yield curvature model considering axial compression ratio

Zhu, Yanyan; Zhong, Jian

doi:10.1186/s43251-023-00099-w

Advances in Bridge Engineering

Table 4 The comparison between experiment and new model

From: A yield curvature model considering axial compression ratio

#	Reference	R_ac	L (m)	f_y (MPa)	Experiment	New model	EN (%)
84	Iwasaki et al. 1985)	0.10	0.20	434	0.01977	0.01747	-11.6
85	Ikeda 1968)	0.10	0.20	434	0.01977	0.01747	-11.6
86	Ikeda 1968)	0.20	0.20	434	0.02219	0.01966	-11.4
87	Ikeda 1968)	0.20	0.20	434	0.02335	0.01966	-15.8
88	Ikeda 1968)	0.10	0.20	345	0.01568	0.01389	-11.4
89	Ikeda 1968)	0.20	0.20	345	0.01796	0.01563	-13.0
90	Ikeda 1968)	0.20	0.20	345	0.01796	0.01563	-13.0
91	Ikeda 1968)	0.22	0.20	462	0.02434	0.02154	-11.5
120	Pandey and Mutsuyoshi 2005)	0.03	0.30	396	0.01110	0.00983	-11.4
122	Yoshimura and Yamanaka 2000)	0.26	0.30	387	0.01457	0.01263	-13.3
127	Ang 1981)	0.38	0.40	427	0.01098	0.01248	13.6
128	Ang 1981)	0.21	0.40	427	0.01037	0.00979	-5.6
129	Soesianawati 1986)	0.10	0.40	446	0.01000	0.00898	-10.2
130	Soesianawati 1986)	0.30	0.40	446	0.01050	0.01154	9.9
132	Soesianawati 1986)	0.30	0.40	446	0.01087	0.01154	6.2
133	Zahn 1985)	0.22	0.40	440	0.01086	0.01026	-5.5
140	Tanaka 1990)	0.20	0.40	474	0.01133	0.01073	-5.3
141	Tanaka 1990)	0.20	0.40	474	0.01133	0.01073	-5.3
142	Tanaka 1990)	0.20	0.40	474	0.01133	0.01073	-5.3
143	Tanaka 1990)	0.20	0.40	474	0.01133	0.01073	-5.3
144	Tanaka 1990)	0.10	0.55	511	0.00776	0.00748	-3.6
145	Tanaka 1990)	0.10	0.55	511	0.00776	0.00748	-3.6
146	Tanaka 1990)	0.30	0.55	511	0.00856	0.00963	12.5
147	Tanaka 1990)	0.30	0.55	511	0.00856	0.00962	12.3
152	Ohno and Nishioka 1984)	0.03	0.40	362	0.00731	0.00677	-7.3
159	Kanda 1988)	0.11	0.25	374	0.01288	0.01212	-5.9
175	Atalay and Penzien 1975)	0.10	0.31	367	0.01064	0.00967	-9.1
177	Atalay and Penzien 1975)	0.10	0.31	367	0.01067	0.00967	-9.4
178	Atalay and Penzien 1975)	0.10	0.31	429	0.01273	0.01137	-10.7
179	Atalay and Penzien 1975)	0.20	0.31	429	0.01479	0.01266	-14.4
180	Atalay and Penzien 1975)	0.18	0.31	429	0.01443	0.01244	-13.8
181	Atalay and Penzien 1975)	0.26	0.31	363	0.01293	0.01163	-10.0
182	Atalay and Penzien 1975)	0.27	0.31	363	0.01298	0.01174	-9.5
183	Atalay and Penzien 1975)	0.28	0.31	363	0.01315	0.01194	-9.2
184	Atalay and Penzien 1975)	0.27	0.31	363	0.01304	0.01183	-9.3
185	Azizinamini et al. 1988)	0.21	0.46	439	0.01021	0.00876	-14.2
186	Azizinamini et al. 1988)	0.31	0.46	439	0.00940	0.01009	7.3
240	Saatcioglu and Grira 1999)	0.20	0.35	455	0.01249	0.01177	-5.8
263	Mo and Wang 2000)	0.11	0.40	497	0.01160	0.01013	-12.7
309	Kono and Watanabe 2000)	0.30	0.25	461	0.01790	0.01909	6.6

EN:100% × (New model—Experiment)/ Experiment

Back to article page