From: Experimental tests and numerical simulations of circular reinforced concrete piers under ship impact
Impact velocity (m/s) | Impact force (kN) | Error | Pier top displacement (mm) | Error | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Test value | FE value | Test value | FE value | |||
1.11 | 90.40 | 82.53 | 8.71% | 35.50 | 37.57 | 5.83% |
2.08 | 176.30 | 151.65 | 13.98% | 73.30 | 65.21 | 11.04% |
3.01 | 148.70 | 152.80 | 2.76% | 98.20 | 116.79 | 18.93% |
4.15 | 102.60 | 96.28 | 6.16% | 137.10 | 178.53 | 30.22% |